Sunday, November 04, 2007

Family Matters

I just read an incredible post by Corner Point on the subject of family--mainly, how each person's family is best for them, tailor-made by Hashem Himself and chosen by the neshama before entering the world. She wrote of her initial disbelief upon hearing this idea, and how it slowly sank in over the years.

I can relate. If you'd told me in high school that my family was the "perfect" one for me, I probably would have laughed in your face. The level of bitterness in the laugh probably would have varied depending on how much criticism I'd received in the near past or how recently I'd been unfavorably compared to my younger sister, but it would have been there. "How can you say that?" I would have exclaimed. "Why, I think they'd hardly notice if I dropped off the face of the earth, except they'd have no one to blame anymore." In most families the younger siblings are always being compared to the older ones and trying to live up to them; in my family, I often felt like my parents should have had my sister first, gotten a dog and lived happily ever after without me. She was the darling, the golden child; I often felt like I could never do anything right or good enough. Additionally, for various reasons, I didn't have exactly what you'd call a normal childhood, and I was forced to grow up far earlier than most of my peers in a lot of ways. "You're telling me that I asked for this in shamayim?!" I'd say. "You must be kidding."

And yet...and yet. Slowly, over the course of many years, and with a farther distance between myself and my family, I began to gain a little perspective. Earliest came peace with my sister, whom I love dearly. I realized that it wasn't her fault we were always compared, nor was it her fault she almost always came out ahead in these comparisons. She never asked to be the golden child, and she was aware of the unfairness of the situation and often took my side and defended me. Then, as I grew older, I became more and more aware of many of my friends' family situations. I began to realize that no family is perfect; indeed, I am surprised many of my friends emerged from theirs with their sanity intact. (For that matter, not all of them did, but most were fortunate.) I learned that I had friends whose parents made mine look positively angelic and doting by comparison. This helped me view my parents, imperfect as they were, in a far more positive light.

As I have grown older and more mature in my perspectives, I have realized that, though my childhood was far from carefree and my parents far from perfect human beings, my experiences shaped who I am as a human being and I could not have been the same Scraps had I led a different life. I've learned many valuable lessons from my family; other things, I'll probably spend my lifetime unlearning. Sure my parents made mistakes...well, they're human, they make mistakes. I'm human too, and G-d knows I make mistakes! So why should I expect any better of them? Their mistakes shaped me as much as their successes, for good and for ill. I recognize now how many of my strengths and good middot I owe to my upbringing, and I would not trade those for any other set of parents in the world.

13 comments:

psyched said...

wow, that was an incredible post. I personally had it out for my family growing up, and only now that I'm "grown up" (haha, still a child at heart) am I able to see how lucky I truly am.

Additionally, going through a difficult time, I am able to see just how loving and caring my immediate family is. Without them, undoubtedly, I would NOT have survived. How sad is it that it takes such trying times in order for us to see that?

Someone very close to me told me a parody you probably have heard before: Many people with an array of problems and complaints gathered around a table. The moderator of the group said, "everyone write your problems on a piece of paper, and put it in the box. Then you'll get rid of yours, and take someone else's." Everyone did just so, and one by one they chose a piece of paper from the box containing someone else's problems.

To make a long story short, every single person gave up and wanted their problems back.

The moral, I think, is... at times we may think that people have it worse, but Hashem knows just what's best for us. While that's so hard to understand and difficult to accept, at the end of the day, our problems were meant just for us.

therapydoc said...

Very powerful, getting to that place where you can see your family as human, not intentionally less-than perfect. So much easier from now on. Except for those times when. . .

Ah, why spoil the honeymoon.

halfshared said...

I have a similar situation where I am compared to my younger sister a lot. My sister, whom I love so so much, is just totally on a different sphere than me. She is the near perfect daughter to my parents and to Hashem. Tznius, eidel, abiding, everything a parent can wish for and I always said I'm glad she came after me cuz otherwise I'd be compared all the time. Silly example, but my sister is very careful about her dress and I have a different level of tznius. Whenever I buy something that my mother isn't sure I should keep, she always says "Would ---wear that"? And I always answer that I'm not younger sister so forget the comparison but I hate it with all my might. I just don't get all hysterical because I can't change my parents so I just learned to accept them for everything good that they are. And again, given the option, I would never trade places for any money in the world!

corner point said...

Beautifully put...

And as we are all products of our upbringing, you're parents--even in their imperfect state--must be amazing people to produce a daughter like you...

Yes.
It's true. Every word.

:)

BEHIND A SMILE said...

It is so easy to judge out parents and decide not to be like them bbut many people turn out just like them and those who take a definate stand and do the opposite...well their children usually decide their way was wrong and end up doing what their g-parents did :)

Scraps said...

psyched--sometimes it's only in the hardest, most difficult times that we learn to appreciate our families the most. It is also sometimes the most difficult times that drive us apart. Really, it all depends on how each family, and each individual member within each family, handles the stress. I've heard that story as well, and I'm not 100% sure I believe it; I'm sure there's someone in this world who I'd trade places with! But I do hear the underlying message, and overall it does have some truth to it.

therapydoc--oh don't worry, you're not spoiling anything. There is no honeymoon, there is no starlight in my eyes. Just because I realize my parents are only human doesn't mean that everything is sunshine and butterflies.

halfshared--I feel your pain. I love my sister dearly, but once in awhile I find myself wishing she wasn't quite so perfect! And I wish my parents would realize that she's not me, and I'm not her, and isn't that allowed? But I'm glad you love and accept your family. :)

CP--oh, one of my "favorite" things when I was younger was when people would meet my parents and tell me how wonderful they were. And of course, if I was in a polite mood, I'd hold back from rolling my eyes, smile politely, and agree with them. If I wasn't feeling so polite...well, it was a little more of an effort. But I guess the consensus is that they're pretty good people. :)

behind a smile--true, some children try to go to opposite extremes to avoid their parents' mistakes and end up messing up just as badly, while others turn into their parents. Can't win, can we? :-P

The Dreamer said...

I think we can allrelate to this post...

Erachet said...

Wow, great post. I really relate to some of the things in here. I periodically wonder how I would survive in another family besides for my own. I often feel very, very lucky to have the parents and siblings that I do because in the environment I grew up in, I was allowed to become the way I am today. I have no idea how comfortable I'd feel in another family.

I really do think families are tailor made, sometimes. Though I guess not ALL the time.

Scraps said...

dreamer--yes, that's probably true.

erachet--it's really a bracha that you're so happy and comfortable with your family. Not everyone is so lucky.

Anonymous said...

Ok enough is enough - I'm protesting

"we want more posts"
"we want more posts"
"we want more posts"

now for the polite version

pretty please with more and ribbons can you write more often since I enjoy reading your posts. Thank you :)

Scraps said...

LOL! I'll do my best, anonymous. I've got a few ideas bouncing around in my head.

In the meantime, why don't you name yourself? I know to know my fans. :)

halfshared said...

I'll echo anonymous with my name. Pretty please with a cherry on top, can you write more often?

Irina Tsukerman said...

I can totally relate to that! I really feel that I've caught a good break with my parents, all my earlier abrasive sentiments notwithstanding... And the rest of the family is not so bad as well. But here's a question: how can a family be perfect if the parents are really selfish or aren't really doing the best they can or are more harsh than necessary, or worse yet, neglectful or abusive? How can it in any way be the most suitable thing for anyone?